Fluffed sequels

[Beardy]

What games did you love, and were super-excited about the sequel, only to be horribly disappointed? Whether it be because the sequel was obviously worse, or just didn't capture that spark that you loved in the first one? Or even where the sequel is obviously better...but you just don't love it as much?

I'd say that Arkham City disappointed me a lot. The gameplay was much better, but it just didn't gel together as a whole like the first one did.

Mario Galaxy 2. I really don't know why.

No More Heroes 2. Another "I'm not sure why" entry.