Seems legit, obviously well researched and discussed.

[Sirion]

Those lists are pure sensationalism. They have no reason but to cause controversy. Read the lists, be happy for the few ones you feel are in a rightfully awarded rank, ignore all the rest. There is no point in comparing Team Fortress 2 with a Legend of Zelda and an Assassin's Creed. We aren't robots with one only thought, neither have experiences and knowledge absorbed the same way in the course of our lives. Those things influence how we think about everything, so there's no way a list like that will ever have a general acceptation. The guys who make these lists know that, they just want attention.